
How to Promote Biblical Virtues Without Sliding Into Moralism
A few weeks back I assigned myself what would appear to be a simple enough task of preparing a sermon on holiness.
I found out it wasn’t simple after all.
I found myself struggling over how I may promote a biblical virtue without degenerating into a kind of a finger-pointing, head-bashing legalism.
This would not have been a problem if God’s call to holiness was merely a good suggestion on His part. But that’s not the case. Quite clearly, God’s call for holy living in Scripture is couched in the imperative mood. He’s not merely suggesting that we be holy. He is commanding us to be holy. You can’t read Hebrews 12 and not notice that the language there smacks of exhortation: “lift your drooping hands”, “strengthen your weak knees”, “make straight paths for your feet”, “strive for holiness, “see to it”. Romans 8 is a clear case in point: “Put to death the deeds of the body”. The verbs “put to death” and “mortify” are in the imperative mood, indicating that this is a divine command.
But here is where the problem starts.
In preaching a biblical virtue like holiness, preachers can easily give the idea that we must all strive for it through sheer grit. People who are already burdened with moralistic tendencies invariably tie those virtues to an angry, transcendentally holy and demanding God, and unwittingly, we will jump through one hoop after another to try to please God.
But an approach like this often ends badly on two counts: if we fail, we feel crushed and plummet into despair. If we succeed, we thumb our noses at others who have failed.
Morality damns in the same way that immorality damns.
So the question still begs to be answered.
How may the preacher commend a biblical virtue such as holiness without sliding into graceless, legalistic moralism?
If we are compelled by biblical teaching both to preach Christ crucified (Acts10:42) and advance virtue (Phil 4:8) then it necessarily follows that the two are not mutually exclusive, and we must be able to do both.
The answer is found in preaching the gospel even as you are promoting biblical virtues. The gospel goes beyond the categories of morality or immorality. It cuts an entirely different angle altogether.
Firstly, the preacher needs to be aware that moralism was never the main thrust of the Old Testament prophets. Neither was it the call of the Messiah and certainly not the rallying cry of the apostles. None of them identified the dividing line in humanity as the line that separates the moral from the immoral, or the virtuous from the defiled.
Instead, the clear teaching is that all humans are immoral. Only in reconciling to God through His Son Jesus Christ will anyone be saved. Morality commends no one to God.
This awareness will help the preacher draw a sharp contrast between the moralistic approach to keeping God’s commandments and the gospel approach to keeping God’s commandments. The moralistic approach tells the people that unless they toe the line, God will not accept them. The gospel approach encourages the listeners to obey God’s commandments out of a deep sense of gratefulness knowing they have already been accepted.
Secondly, the preacher needs to emphasise the point that we obey God’s command to be holy not because obedience secures us God’s favour, but because there is an evidence of holiness that is required of God’s people not so that they might be made justified but to validate and confirm that they are indeed justified. How wonderfully light the commandment becomes just knowing that holiness is the fruit of our union with Christ.
Thirdly, the preacher may want to remind the people that we’re not left mercilessly without help in our striving for holiness. Apart from the gift of the gospel, our loving Father has also given us the help of the Holy Spirit, coupled with such means of grace as the Holy Communion and the fellowship of Church to aid us in our pursuit for holiness
At this point, the preacher needs to get the people to look to Jesus.
If the bad news is that we all stand filthy before God because of our sins, then the good news is that Jesus, the Holy One, who is pure and sinless, took on our sin and depravity and absorbed the wrath of God that rightly should’ve fallen on us, so that we might be accepted as pure and holy. The Holy One was made vile so that we might be made holy.
To the degree your flock understands the cross, their obedience to His commands will come from a place of love for Him and not from a compulsion to be morally upright for fear of His disapproval.
(To read a sermon Andrew preached on this issue – click here)